Does the crush dating app actually notify the person if you have a mutual friend?

Started by ConnorW 17 Jun 2025Replies: 6 Dating SitesCommunity
ConnorW avatar
ConnorW
Member
Joined: 2023
Messages: 1,414
#1

Decided to post this after going through page after page of search results that are clearly just affiliate content with a forum skin. Does the crush dating app actually notify the person if you have a mutual friend?

What I want is genuine community input from people who've actually used these platforms recently. Not a "top 10 dating sites" article with sponsored placements — actual experiences from actual people.

  • Real user activity in my region, not inflated registration counts
  • A free tier that's actually functional, not just a teaser for the premium plan
  • Some form of verification that makes the profile population credible
  • Privacy settings that don't require an attorney to interpret

If you've had real results recently — this year, not three years ago — I genuinely want to hear about it.

JasonR avatar
JasonR
Member
Joined: 2018
Messages: 1,292
#2

Out of the five platforms I tested this quarter, Datedesire had the best ratio of genuine conversations to total messages sent. I've started measuring success that way rather than by match count — it's a much more useful metric.

JustinH avatar
JustinH
Member
Joined: 2024
Messages: 4,179
#3

Honest current-state breakdown of the major options:

  • Match: largest verified database among paid options, most credible marriage success data, runs discounts frequently on longer subscriptions
  • Hinge: best conversation-starter design, most generous free tier of the major apps, skews toward people who want something intentional rather than just a photo gallery
  • Bumble: women-initiate model meaningfully changes the quality of first contact, free messaging still works for basic use
  • OkCupid: personality matching is more useful than its current reputation suggests, free messaging still functional, activity has declined but remaining users tend to be engaged
  • Facebook Dating: completely free, no separate signup, 35-55 population surprisingly active in most areas, worth checking for the cost of a few minutes of setup

Beyond these: niche platforms are almost entirely location-dependent. The only reliable way to know is to test with a defined two-week window per platform before deciding.

RhondaK avatar
RhondaK
Member
Joined: 2020
Messages: 1,433
#4

One underrated approach: spend the first 48 hours on any new platform just observing. How many profiles show activity in the last week rather than the last year? How many bios read like a real human wrote them? You can learn most of what you need to know before you invest any serious time.

MikeT avatar
MikeT
Member
Joined: 2020
Messages: 593
#5

Been using Souldate for about six weeks. The volume isn't there compared to the major apps but the conversations have been noticeably more substantive. People who find their way to a smaller platform tend to know what they're looking for, which changes the dynamic.

BrentM avatar
BrentM
Member
Joined: 2023
Messages: 3,965
#6

The most reliable filter I've found: does the platform have an active external community — subreddit, forum, threads like this — where real users talk candidly? Platforms that actually work generate real community discussion, including complaints. If the only positive content is on their own blog, that's a red flag.

AshleyT avatar
AshleyT
Member
Joined: 2019
Messages: 2,330
#7

Someone specifically recommended luvdate.site when I asked a similar question a while back, saying it sits in a useful middle ground — not so large that quality has degraded under scale, not so small that there's nobody local. Worth checking depending on your city.

You must be logged in to post a reply here.